There are 12 former lookout sites registered in New York. The most recently registered former lookout site is Makomis Fire Tower Original Site (US 2102, NY 13), added on December 31, 2023.
| Lookout Name | NHLR Registry Number | Available for Rental | Visit Reports |
| Bayshore Lookout Site | US 551, NY 4 | ||
| Camp Upton North Tower Site | US 524, NY 1 | ||
| Camp Upton South Tower Site | US 525, NY 2 | ||
| Dix Hill Lookout Site | US 552, NY 6 | ||
| Flanders Hill Lookout Site | US 553, NY 7 | ||
| Jersey Hill Lookout Site | US 1595, NY 12 | ||
| Kings Park Lookout Site | US 554, NY 8 | ||
| Makomis Fire Tower Original Site | US 2102, NY 13 | ||
| Spy Rock Lookout Site | US 696, NY 11 | ||
| Stony Hill Lookout Site | US 555, NY 9 | ||
| Telescope Hill Lookout Site | US 556, NY 10 | ||
| Washburn Mountain Tower Site | US 545, NY 3 |